The Website of The Magazine of the Science Fiction & Fantasy Field

Locus Online
   locus magazine banner
Sub Menu contents


Recent Posts

Categories

Archives

 




 

Citizen Flynn: A Review of Tron: Legacy


by Gary Westfahl

Whatever else one might say about Tron: Legacy, it must first be recognized as a superb example of film considered as an amusement park ride, and most audiences will readily succumb to the sheer, exhilarating thrill of its first hour, as protagonist Sam Flynn (Garrett Hedlund) is drawn into a well-realized computer world, based upon that of the original Tron (1982) but technically superior, and finds himself involved in a series of fast-paced battles and chases, enhanced by an unusually restrained use of 3-D effects. While its second hour lags a bit, with quieter intervals for info-dumping and character development, there are still striking moments of shock and awe to keep one enthralled as the film advances toward its inevitable but satisfying happy ending. When the sleazy Zuse (Michael Sheen) tells Sam that “It’s going to be quite a ride,” he defines the essence of a film that invites viewers to turn off their critical faculties and immerse themselves in the experience of racing through a colorful fantasy landscape, and unlike other films of its genre, Tron: Legacy immunizes itself against criticism by openly acknowledging its very nature: the film both is, and is about, a computer-generated imaginary world crafted by human beings for their own entertainment. One cannot complain that a certain sequence is like something from a video game, because that, in a sense, is the point.

However, while there is something to be said for film reviews that simply advise readers to grab some popcorn and enjoy the show, that has never been my specialty, and when I watched Tron: Legacy for a second time and actually began to think about what was going on, I reached the conclusion that, in addition to its overt commentary on people who construct and inhabit their own realities, this is also a film that is in fascinating dialogue with Orson Welles’ and Herman J. Mankiewicz’s classic Citizen Kane (1941).

But before explicating these connections, some background information is in order. To set its game of cops and robbers in motion, the first film drew upon familiar themes: corporate greed and the oppression of the masses. Both in the real world and within his computer world, programmer Kevin Flynn (Jeff Bridges) must battle against corporate mogul Ed Dillinger (David Warner), who has stolen his game ideas, taken over his company, and established a virtual dictatorship over sympathetic programs like Tron (Bruce Boxleitner) who become Flynn’s allies after Dillinger traps him inside the Grid. The story of Tron: Legacy involves a similar conflict: Dillinger is no longer around, but his spirit is represented by current company head Richard Mackey (Jeffrey Nordling) and his subordinate Edward Dillinger (Gillian Murphy), Dillinger’s son, who are dedicated to maximizing profits by overcharging customers, as Flynn’s former colleague Alan Bradley (Bruce Boxleitner) points out during a board meeting. Flynn himself has been missing for twenty years, but his son and heir Sam, still the largest stockholder, allows Mackey to stay in control while regularly bedeviling him with damaging pranks like making the company’s latest operating system available for free on the Internet. Once Sam himself has been drawn into a computer world, he meets his aging father (Jeff Bridges) and joins him in battling against a new menace, the program Clu (“codified likeness utility”) (Jeff Bridges); while created by Kevin Flynn in his image to serve as an assistant, Clu has overthrown his master, made himself a dictator, and now plots to conquer the real world as well. The Flynns’ chief ally is now a representative of a new underclass, Quorra (Olivia Wilde), the sole survivor of a race of “Isos,” “isomorphic algorithms” and “a whole new life form” discovered within the Grid.

However, unlike his father, who had been reduced by Dillinger’s machinations to supporting himself by running a video arcade, Sam Flynn seems a peculiarly privileged champion of the working class. We see this in the opening sequence as he blithely speeds through traffic on his motorcycle, breaks into company headquarters, steals its data, and is finally captured by police after he parachutes off the building. But in a telling moment, he is soon walking out of the police station, clearly freed by a high-priced lawyer who will protect him from any further legal consequences, while a police officer walks toward the station holding two men who will undoubtedly find it more difficult to get out of jail. He also enjoys special protection inside the computer world: after beating two opponents in battles with flying disks, a third opponent is about to kill him when a drop of blood reveals that Sam is a “user,” a human programmer; his life spared, he is granted an audience with Clu, who determines that this worthy foe should not merely be slaughtered, but allowed to participate in one more game with Clu himself as one of the opponents. Needless to say, he also survives this battle when he is providently rescued by Quorra and taken to see his father, now living outside the virtual city in a stark but luxurious suite. The pattern is obvious: in both the real and virtual worlds, Sam, unlike the genuinely oppressed people and programs around him, can always escape from the consequences of his misdeeds.

To be sure, Tron: Legacy is hardly the first film to feature a powerful, aristocratic hero who fights for powerless poor people, since this is a trope that uniquely appeals to two conflicting impulses in typical audiences. Regarding themselves as victimized by various overlords in their own daily lives, most filmgoers are receptive to the general message that such figures must be opposed in order to promote the interests of ordinary working-class folk; yet they also like to imagine themselves as someday becoming wealthy, and want to vicariously enjoy the lifestyles of the rich and famous. The obvious solution is to present a privileged protagonist, enjoying the most desirable luxuries, who escapes opprobrium because he works on behalf of the oppressed masses; I mean, would anybody really want to watch a hero who returns from his adventures to a shabby apartment in some ghetto? Sam Flynn, then, is merely one of countless figures in a tradition that includes Zorro, Batman, and the Green Hornet (whose upcoming film was previewed in the theatre where I watched Tron: Legacy); and if these icons’ charitable impulses seem improbable, one can point to real-life examples, like members of the Kennedy family, of plutocrats who vigorously promoted the interests of the less fortunate.

Yet the value of Citizen Kane lies in its recognition that such people might be driven by questionable motives that would ultimately prevent them from achieving their seemingly desirable aims. Born to be leaders, these upper-class heroes do not genuinely seek to free the masses from oppression, but rather to replace their old boss with a new boss (themselves); and while they might imagine that their rule will be more enlightened than that of their predecessors, the people whose interests they are purportedly championing might recognize and resent their autocratic aspirations. Furthermore, if they achieve the status they aspire to, we don’t need Pete Townsend to remind us that the new boss always tends to become “just like the old boss.”

One will search hard for intimations of these problems in most stories about superheroes (though one might mention, say, Denny O’Neill’s Green Lantern/Green Arrow stories or Alan Moore’s Watchmen series), but one of the ways that Tron: Legacy outshines its predecessor is the way that its portrayal of the elderly Kevin Flynn, carefully examined, suggests what might eventually happen to youthful heroes like his son Sam. While motivated solely to create “a perfect system” with his Grid, Kevin Flynn essentially made himself the dictator of his own world, and he created Clu specifically to work as his servant. But who wants to be a permanent servant? There may be a few exceptional individuals like Tron, who figures fleetingly in this film (as in the original) as a representative of the contented subordinate who is always happy to “fight for the users,” but most people would come to resent their lowly status and seek to overthrow their master, even if that person regarded himself as a benign ruler. Clu’s “coup,” then, is perfectly understandable, and one could have tweaked the story to make him more sympathetic, at least at the onset, as he removes the Grid’s despot and undertakes to improve the status of all its citizens. And his announced goal of liberating his programs to occupy the real world has a certain amount of justice and logic on its side: if we could make computer programs into people who could enjoy normal lives, instead of a stark existence inside an artificial construct, aren’t we obliged to do exactly that?

But Tron: Legacy is designed to avoid raising such questions by portraying Clu as a man corrupted by power: despite his rhetoric, we know that he is not really motivated by any desire to improve the lot of his subjects, as we can tell by the brusque way that he constantly dismisses the aspirations of his lackey Jarvis (James Frain), and by his habit of killing subordinates who displease him. In other words, he has become precisely the sort of person that he once despised. It is less obvious that Kevin Flynn is open to criticism on similar grounds, although the man himself eventually recognizes and acknowledges that the whole situation confronting Sam was really his own fault. In this respect, there are clear parallels between Kevin Flynn and Charles Foster Kane: both men sought to become the champions of the people in the world they lived in (Kane, as a muckraking newspaper publisher and potential governor; Flynn, as master of the computer programs within his Grid). They both became more devoted to promoting their own interests (Kane, his romance with Susan Alexander; Flynn, his obsessive pursuit of perfection). Both were ultimately rejected by the people they sought to rule (Kane, by losing the election and failing to promote the career of his second wife; Flynn, by being overthrown by Clu). And both men then retreated to a luxurious home, far away from the concerns of the world, and dedicated themselves to relaxed inactivity (Kane, having parties at Xanadu; Flynn, meditating in his suite outside the Grid city).

The difference between the films, of course, is that Tron: Legacy, designed to function as popular entertainment, must have a happy ending, however contrived that might seem. Imagine an alternate version of Citizen Kane that concludes when the aged Kane is suddenly approached by a son and daughter he had lost track of long ago and is urged to abandon Xanadu and to join them in mounting one last campaign to oust mean old Boss Gettys from power once and for all. Then, after he improbably succeeds, Kane is finally vindicated, as he belatedly becomes the true champion of the masses that he always wanted to be. As a conclusion to Welles’ and Mankiewicz’s masterpiece, it doesn’t sound very appropriate, to say the least, but it is precisely the sort of rousing ending that Hollywood loves, and it’s hard to complain about seeing a film like Tron: Legacy move in this direction. The surprise is that such a film would sketch a more somber scenario at some length before rejecting it in favor of conventional uplift.

None of this, though, is intended to suggest that the multiple authors of Tron: Legacy set out to create a film that would thoughtfully explore the implications of failed heroism; rather, they were forced to confront this theme due to the unique requirement that they find a meaningful role for a sixty-year-old actor who, even with computer enhancement, could not persuasively portray a character under forty. Their solution was to employ the real Jeff Bridges as an elderly man inspired to interrupt his retirement by younger protagonists who could do all the heavy lifting for the plot, while a cybernetically-airbrushed Bridges could be deployed more sporadically to serve as the film’s villain. And, as occurred in the later Star Trek films with the original cast, when you bring old people into young people’s stories, incongruous topics like the effects of aging, disillusionment, and reconsiderations of youthful proclivities inexorably come to the forefront.

Also, when you place a greybeard inside what seems a virtual world for adolescents, the danger of spending too much time with fantasy instead of reality becomes an implicit message. This is another way to characterize Kane’s problems, since after he fails to conquer the real world, he sets out to create and rule his own little kingdom of Xanadu, only to find with his wife’s departure that he cannot even be successful at that. In the case of Kevin Flynn, he got into trouble precisely because he was spending too much time constructing his perfect Grid and not enough time playing with his young son Sam (Owen Best). It is interesting that both Tron films, apparent celebrations of video games, characterize their computer-generated playgrounds as places that people are desperately striving to escape from, as they prefer actual lives over virtual lives; characters liken their existence within the Grid to being inside “a safe” or “a cage.”

There is also a striking visual indication that lingering too long in unreality can be hazardous to your health, though mentioning it requires me to “reveal,” if that is the word, that Sam ultimately gets out of the Grid and back to the real world. (But could anyone really expect the film to end with Sam killed or permanently imprisoned in the Grid? Surely, the only genuine suspense in the film involves not whether he escapes, but precisely how he escapes, which I’m not discussing.) Throughout the film, as is fitting for a world inside a machine, Flynn’s construct is shown as relentlessly monochromatic, mostly various shades of blue, though the dark outfits of good characters are highlighted in white while the outfits of evil characters are highlighted in yellow or orange. To contrastingly illustrate the joys of living in the real world, one would expect Sam to emerge into a riotous assemblage of bright colors, which might be a welcome sight for color-starved filmgoers. But he actually steps out into a cloudy day of rather subdued colors, suggesting that if you spend too much time in cyberspace, you might bring some of its atmosphere back with you.

To underscore its various themes, the film offers a rich range of references to distinguished precursors, perhaps reflecting the combined knowledge base of its four credited writers. It is a nice touch that both young Sam’s bedroom and Kevin Flynn’s retreat include shelves full of books, the original device that people employed to escape from their everyday worlds, and that Chorra is a particular fan of the novels of Jules Verne, who arguably established the modern tradition of stories about adventurers into exotic realms. In contrast, while Kevin Flynn’s shelves include works by Tolstoy and Dostoyevsky and the I Ching, his favorite book seems to be Chogyam Trungpa’s Journey without Goal: The Tantric Wisdom of the Buddha (1981), which would account for his inclination to meditate instead of taking action. In commenting on the surprise of having the creator’s son walk into his establishment, Zuse delivers a version of Rick Blaine’s classic line from Casablanca (1942), “Of all the gin joints, in all the towns, in all the world, she walks into mine”; and come to think of it, that is another story about an older man who withdraws into a world of his own until a figure from his past arrives to reignite his passion for justice. And, since one might say the same about Obi Wan Kenobi, it’s understandable that one scene of aerial combat within the Grid is explicitly modeled on the final scene of Star Wars (1977). (There is a poster on Sam’s wall from another space film of that era, The Black Hole [1979], though that seems primarily an in-joke about director Joseph Kosinski’s next assignment, a remake of that film.) When Sam walks into his father’s abandoned arcade, the songs being played are Journey’s “Separate Ways (Worlds Apart)” and the Eurythmics’ “Sweet Dreams (Are Made of This)”; not only are the titles obviously relevant to the film’s events, but both songs debuted in early 1983, shortly after the film’s release and, presumably, the time when Kevin Flynn, now back into control of his company, would have shut down his arcade. Kevin describes the Isos as “flowers in the wasteland,” using the title of Lisa Chappell’s 2006 song, whose opening stanza might describe the situation of everyone inside the Grid: “A flower in the wasteland / Caught between nowhere and no place / A ray of light in the endless night / A night of broken promises, lost hope and stolen dreams.” And prominently on display in Kevin’s room is a bowl full of silver apples, which for some might recall W. B. Yeats’ 1899 poem, “The Song of Wandering Aengus,” wherein a man “old with wandering” resolves to go in search of a beautiful woman “And pluck till time and times are done, / The silver apples of the moon, / The golden apples of the sun.”

Still, despite all of these intriguing clues, I am not sure how far one should take the search for deeper meanings within Tron: Legacy, bearing in mind the lessons of the film. Would such analysis be a genuine service to a film that might otherwise be insufficiently appreciated, or would it rather represent an arrogant effort to assert control over a perceived subordinate in the manner of Kane and the earlier Flynn? Would efforts to find significance in every moment of this film constitute an obsessive quest for “perfection,” which is precisely the way that Kevin Flynn, in his own words, “screwed it up”? Perhaps, then, it would be best to follow my original advice and relish the journey of Tron: Legacy without worrying about its goal, though that is not the game that I usually play.

Gary Westfahl’s works include the Hugo-nominated Science Fiction Quotations: From the Inner Mind to the Outer Limits (2005) and The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Science Fiction and Fantasy (2005); samples from these and his other works are available at his World of Westfahl website. His recent books include the Second Edition of Islands in the Sky: The Space Station Theme in Science Fiction Literature (2009), its companion text The Other Side of the Sky: An Annotated Bibliography of Space Stations in Science Fiction, 1869-1993 (2009), and the forthcoming co-edited anthology Science Fiction and the Prediction of the Future.

Comments

Pingback from ‘Tron Legacy’ Is A Virtual Hit At The Weekend Box Office – MTV.com | Breaking News
Time December 20, 2010 at 10:03 am

[...] Legacy Downloads Box Office First Place FinishTheHDRoomA New Tron Bomb?E! Online (blog)Locus Online -TV.com -Reutersall 1,077 news [...]

Pingback from Tweets that mention Locus Online Reviews » Citizen Flynn: A Review of Tron: Legacy — Topsy.com
Time December 20, 2010 at 10:19 am

[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by JK. JK said: Citizen Flynn: A Review of Tron: Legacy http://bit.ly/h5NBYW [...]

Pingback from Citizen Flynn: A Review of Tron: Legacy – Locus Online | New Computers Today
Time December 20, 2010 at 2:42 pm

[...] webmaster@technorati.com wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerpt [...]

Pingback from Citizen Flynn: A Review of Tron: Legacy – Locus Online | Peoples Program Scam
Time December 20, 2010 at 3:32 pm

[...] Citizen Flynn: A Review &#959f Tron: LegacyLocus OnlineTh&#1077 pattern &#1110&#1109 obvious: &#1110n both th&#1077 real &#1072nd virtual worlds, Sam, unlike th&#1077 genuinely oppressed people &#1072nd programs around h&#1110m, &#1089&#1072n always escape fr&#959m th&#1077 …Tron: Legacy Downloads Box Office First Pl&#1072&#1089&#1077 EndTheHDRoomTron: Legacy &#959n iMax 3D Doesn't Disappoint! Michelle's ReviewTV.comMovie Review: 'Tron: Legacy' &#1072&#1109 artificial &#1072&#1109 th&#1077 virtual world &#1110t's set &#1110nHeritage Newspapers [...]

Pingback from Movie studio MGM emerges from bankruptcy – Reuters » SKY DIGITAL/BROADBAND REGISTRATION
Time December 20, 2010 at 8:34 pm

[...] LegacyDaily Illini (blog)'Tron' Leads Box Office With $44 Million in SalesBusinessWeekLocus Online -Film School Rejects -Reutersall 1,217 news [...]

Pingback from Tron frozen out, Burlesque can’t tickle a fancy and Fred clams up – The Guardian (blog) | linknrj
Time December 21, 2010 at 6:04 am

[...] 'Tron: Evolution'In Utah This WeekTron: LegacyDaily Illini (blog)BusinessWeek -Locus Online -Film School Rejectsall 1,276 news [...]

Pingback from tron reviews | Regedit Cleaner
Time December 29, 2010 at 4:20 am

[...] Citizen Flynn: A Review of Tron: Legacy – Locus Online Citizen Flynn: A Review of Tron: LegacyLocus Online… film reviews that simply advise readers to grab some popcorn and enjoy the show, that has never been my specialty, and when I watched Tron: Legacy for a …Film Review: Tron: Legacy GamePro.comWeekend Box Office Review (12/19/10): Tron: Legacy stays above water, How Do … Huffington Post (blog)Reviews: Is 'Tron: Legacy' confusing? 'How Do You Know'? Dallas Morning News (blog)Stuff.co.nz -Reviews Of Electronics -New Zealand Heraldall 1,408 news articles » Dec 18, 2010 4:50am [...]

Comment from Gregory Gunther
Time January 4, 2011 at 6:53 am

I enjoyed your insightful review of TRON: Legacy, but Citizen Kane, really. Certainly Sam Flynn is somewhat represented an a privileged protagonist. I think this was more in play as an easy plot device to explain how the Flynn’s could keep an old arcade (complete with all the old vintage games in it for over twenty years — I mean even if you had money, why would you do that,) rather than to make him a hero for the underprivileged masses. Sure, the Flynn’s support Open Source software, but does that make them champions against our corporate overlords.

For me the movie is straight up Hero’s Journey. You can clearly see all the stages, ‘The Call to Action’, ‘The Refusal’, ‘Crossing the Threshold,’ ‘Atonement with the Father’, etc. Probably the whole corporate greed thing in the beginning is to just show that even in the ‘ordinary, real’ world, how Sam refuses to take up his responsibility or dare I say it, destiny.

I have been fortunate to seen this film 3 times, and while it has glaring plot holes, and too much exposition, there are lots of elements that work amazingly well to create something wonderful to watch, especially in IMAX 3D.

There are a few sequences in TRON: Legacy that are just masterfully done. The opening scene from the GRID to Flynn’s back door, the news cycle of his disappearance (from the old TVs to Sam looking out the window), of course the LightCycle battle, the End of Line club, and the LightPlane sequence. Outside of the action, the film really falters, in terms of plot and pacing. What ties the whole film together is Daft Punk music. It truly captures the tone and mood of the visuals and almost become the most important character in the film.

I have read other reviews that have talked about how sparse and empty the GRID world seems to be. I would agree. Outside of our five or six main characters, all the other ‘programs’ are irrelevant. The main characters are all well represented if somewhat one-dimensional. We have Sam (the hero), Kevin Flynn (the old, wizard), CLU (the evil shadow (who is really Kevin’s lack of understanding, not Sam’s), and Quorra (the boon) (who is quite possibly the best character in the film.)

Sam must have been an underwear model in a past life as he spends more than a few scenes in the moving ‘walking’ like on a runway. One must also wonder, why if Kevin Flynn has such power over and in the GRID that he can’t beat his opponent. They try to explain this away as they did everything else, with a ‘the harder I fight, the stronger he gets’ statement. But I don’t see CLU having any real power other than perhaps he is a better leader or the programs are more afraid of him. Elder Flynn just seems like an old hippie, that wants to stay hidden away in his yoga retreat. He doesn’t even seem that grateful that his son is trying to rescue him. Of course 20 years trapped in a bleak, computer world might just make one as apathetic as he seems to be.

All in all, the movie was quite entertaining, with the visual and musical elements get going in full swing. The GRID is an interesting place, but I wouldn’t want to live there.
In the end, it seems the message is not as much about corporate greed, or losing control of technology, but that given true freedom, even programs, in the end would prefer to rule themselves in their own way. Just like us.

Comment from Dejiridoo
Time January 4, 2011 at 9:40 am

I think this is a thoughtful article that delves deeply into the themes of fatherhood and the comparison of Tron: Legacy to Citizen Kane is original. This movie is so steeped in sci-fi culture and lore that it is difficult to review the film objectively. I agree that class issues played a significant role–but more in the sense that wealth was celebrated and so was its excess. In that respect, the film is consistent with pop-culture of the second decade of this millennium, in which “I want to be a billionaire” is a top-ten global hit and Facebook and Apple drive stock markets.

That said, the film did let me down in several ways and I think it’s fair to criticize it. I felt the acting was on the whole terrible, with the exception of Jeff Bridges, who also incidentally saved the first movie. Garett Hedlund was simply not suited for the role of Sam and Chris Pine (of Star Trek) could have played the role with more nuance and humor. While many of the storylines that you described sound plausible when you relate them, I thought they were poorly executed, with intriguing plotliines such as Edward Dillinger’s son petering out into nothing. (It’s a shame, as Gillian Murphy is a talented actor.) The most compelling actor to me, besides Bridges, was Michael Sheen, but his wild dance scene so closely mimicked that of the Merivingian in the Matrix series that it could only be considered derivative (enjoyably derivative at that).

I still found Tron: Legacy to be a visual feast and I think the creative forces in this project were not the writers, but set designers and CGI artists. That is the story of Tron: Legacy to me, the fact that these creative artists expanded upon the visual elements of the story in innovative ways, elaborating and even eclipsing the original with taste and respect. This is one film that may actually be better in video game form, and there’s nothing wrong with that.

–Dejiridoo

Comment from Eurico de Barros
Time January 21, 2011 at 2:37 pm

Hollywood “sci-fi” at its worst, a total waste of everything, from the actors to the 3D.

Comment from davidgswanger
Time January 25, 2011 at 7:03 pm

Among the other allusions to classic films is the elder Flynn’s retreat, which strongly resembles the room at the climax of 2001, a movie that would surely have been among his favorites.


© 2012-2014 by Locus Publications. All rights reserved. Powered by WordPress, modified from a theme design by Lorem Ipsum